The Mouse – Good or Bad?
I wanted to reflect on this earlier in the week but have only just had time.
On Wednesday, I had a PSHE slot which, due to unforseen circumstances, had no planning attached to it. I had the lunch hour to think of a way to use the 40 minute session, but it had to be something about this half term’s value – honesty. It got to ten to one and I was struggling to find inspiration on the internet.
I read a story to my class at the end of every day. Sometimes it’s from a picture book, sometimes a section from our longer story (at the moment it’s George’s Marvellous Medicine!) and sometimes one from a site I like to use online. This particular day I had picked The Gruffalo, one of their favourites, as we hadn’t read it yet this term. It was sitting on my desk, ready for the end of the day when I realised that honesty is one of the themes in the story. After all, the mouse spends a large amount of time lying to different animals and creating this imaginary creature (who, of course, turns out not to be imaginary after all!)
I realised I might be able to get some quality thinking going on.
When my class came in from lunch, I read them the story. I asked them whether all the animals were being honest and they were unsure. So I read it to them again, only this time I asked them to listen very carefully and try to think about whether the the animals were being entirely truthful. As I read, there were gasps as it dawned on them that the mouse was lying to all the other animals. I was surprised they had not realised it before, but was glad that they were so interested in the mouse and his dishonesty. Afterwards, I asked the children to talk with their partner about two things.
1. Was the mouse being honest?
2. If not, why?
When they fed back, the whole class agreed that the mouse was not being honest because he did not want to be eaten. They talked about how he had lied to the animals who wanted to eat him and The Gruffalo at the end. Next I asked the children this:
Is the mouse bad because he has been dishonest?
There was silence! (This does not happen often – I have a class of chatterboxes!) After a while one of the boys said that he was only telling lies so he didn’t get eaten and that if he had told the truth, he would have died. This made the others think. Had the mouse been bad by telling lies to save his life?
We talked for a further twenty minutes about the choices the mouse had made and that he hadn’t told lies to hurt anyone, merely to save his own skin! At the end, I asked them if there are times when it is ok to lie to someone? They had really gotten into the lesson and were already thinking of characters in other books who had lied like the mouse. I was pleased with how much they had really thought about honesty and whether there are times when it’s acceptable.
Just shows how sometimes the best lessons are completely off the cuff!